West Virginia Lawyers Directory
Instant Court Records Search
Criminal Court Records, Civil Court Records, Traffic Court Records
Federal, State, County & Municipal Sources and Much More!
Search for Cases from January 19, 1972 to July 13, 2022
A (4476 rec) B (4869 rec) C (7339 rec) D (7594 rec) E (3021 rec) F (1110 rec) G (2473 rec) H (1343 rec) I (567 rec) J (9331 rec) K (4265 rec) L (6030 rec) M (8343 rec) N (1727 rec) O (378 rec) P (3887 rec) Q (19 rec) R (6071 rec) S (7268 rec) T (4873 rec) U (413 rec) V (1659 rec) W (1872 rec) X (9 rec) Y (254 rec) Z (99 rec)| Plaintiff / Defendant Name |
Petitioner / Respondent Name |
Filed, Nature of Suit, Judge |
|---|---|---|
|
Orpha Hofstetter
More Information |
Mentor Worldwide LLC, Inc., American Medical Systems, Coloplast Corp. | Filed: May 15, 2013 # 2:2013cv11363 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Otis Collier
More Information Janice Collier More Information |
LLC, Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon, Inc. | Filed: October 01, 2013 # 2:2013cv24119 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Osmond Elliston
More Information Michelle A. Elliston More Information |
Coloplast Corp. | Filed: September 24, 2013 # 2:2013cv23535 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Opal Nichols
More Information Charles Nichols More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: May 02, 2013 # 2:2013cv10008 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Omar Tornavaca
More Information Teresa Rodriguez More Information |
Ethicon, Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, Boston Scientific Corporation, LLC, Inc. | Filed: September 16, 2013 # 2:2013cv23084 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oscar L. Gutierrez
More Information Delia Gutierrez More Information |
American Medical Systems, Inc. | Filed: April 30, 2013 # 2:2013cv09604 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Okboon Brown
More Information |
Coloplast Corp. | Filed: September 03, 2013 # 2:2013cv22491 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Onorina Guido
More Information |
Inc., C. R. Bard | Filed: April 24, 2013 # 2:2013cv08911 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ollie M. Hammonds
More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: August 01, 2013 # 2:2013cv21374 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ora Elizabeth Cunningham Autrey
More Information Curtis A. Autrey More Information |
American Medical Systems, Inc. | Filed: April 11, 2013 # 2:2013cv07831 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ortha Cupp
More Information |
Coloplast Corp., Mentor Worldwide LLC | Filed: July 30, 2013 # 2:2013cv21226 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olin Wolf
More Information Lena Wolf More Information |
American Medical Systems, Inc. | Filed: July 29, 2013 # 2:2013cv21136 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olivia Mouchet
More Information |
Ethicon, Inc., Ethicon, LLC, Johnson & Johnson | Filed: July 22, 2013 # 2:2013cv20781 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olene Gibson
More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: April 04, 2013 # 2:2013cv07154 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oralene Frances Worthington
More Information |
Inc., LLC, Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon, Ethicon | Filed: July 13, 2013 # 2:2013cv20277 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ordie Cherry
More Information |
Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: July 10, 2013 # 2:2013cv18452 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Odilia Monico
More Information |
Inc., C. R. Bard | Filed: July 10, 2013 # 2:2013cv18728 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olga Salas
More Information |
Inc., C. R. Bard, Tissue Science Laboratories Limited | Filed: July 08, 2013 # 2:2013cv17789 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Odell Briones
More Information |
Ethicon, Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, LLC, Inc. | Filed: July 03, 2013 # 2:2013cv17242 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ortha Conner
More Information Yvette Conner More Information |
American Medical Systems, Ethicon, LLC, Inc., Johnson & Johnson, Inc., Boston Scientific Corporation, Ethicon | Filed: July 01, 2013 # 2:2013cv16656 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Orlando Jaramillo
More Information Cornelia Jaramillo More Information |
American Medical Systems, Inc. | Filed: June 29, 2013 # 2:2013cv16479 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olivia Brannan
More Information Charles Brannan More Information |
Ethicon, Ethicon, LLC, Inc., Johnson & Johnson | Filed: March 11, 2013 # 2:2013cv04848 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ofelia Gonzalez
More Information Jose Sanchez More Information |
Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: June 29, 2013 # 2:2013cv16517 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oleta F. Wetherell
More Information |
Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, Inc., Ethicon, LLC | Filed: March 01, 2013 # 2:2013cv04029 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oneida S. Hill
More Information Thomas J. Hill More Information |
Ethicon, LLC, Ethicon, Inc., Johnson & Johnson, Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: March 04, 2013 # 2:2013cv04100 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olivia Rico
More Information Luis Rico More Information |
Ethicon, Inc., Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon, LLC | Filed: February 28, 2013 # 2:2013cv03860 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olga Lydia Bravo
More Information Javier Bravo More Information |
Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: June 19, 2013 # 2:2013cv14835 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Odessa Jackson
More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: June 26, 2013 # 2:2013cv15888 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olivia Rueda
More Information Enrique M. Rueda More Information |
Inc., C. R. Bard | Filed: February 07, 2013 # 2:2013cv02175 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olga Grasso
More Information |
Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: June 11, 2013 # 2:2013cv13989 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Otis Mae Wilson
More Information |
Inc., C. R. Bard | Filed: February 07, 2013 # 2:2013cv02234 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olga S. Nino
More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: May 28, 2013 # 2:2013cv12466 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oscar Dima
More Information San Juanita De Leon More Information |
Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon, LLC, Ethicon, Inc. | Filed: June 07, 2013 # 2:2013cv13706 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Orman Hartranft
More Information Annette Hartranft More Information |
Inc., Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson | Filed: January 21, 2013 # 2:2013cv01187 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ollie Biggers
More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: June 18, 2013 # 2:2013cv14770 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oscar Robichaud
More Information Donna Robichaud More Information |
Endo Health Solutions Inc., Inc., American Medical Systems Holdings, Inc., Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: January 08, 2013 # 2:2013cv00297 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Omeca L. Humphrey
More Information Christian Hull More Information |
Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: May 01, 2013 # 2:2013cv09758 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olga Gonzalez
More Information Raul Gonzalez More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: April 26, 2013 # 2:2013cv09219 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oleta M. Allen
More Information Michael C. Allen More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: December 06, 2012 # 2:2012cv08580 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Opal J. McClure
More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: April 26, 2013 # 2:2013cv09160 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Odilia Rodriguez
More Information |
American Medical Systems Holdings, Inc., Inc., American Medical Systems, Endo Health Solutions Inc., Inc., Endo Pharmaceuticals | Filed: November 13, 2012 # 2:2012cv07724 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ollie Hoops‚ Jr.
More Information Tammie Y. Hoops More Information |
Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: March 22, 2013 # 2:2013cv06028 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ora Kay Gray
More Information Clarence Allen Gray More Information |
Inc., Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon, LLC, Ethicon | Filed: November 01, 2012 # 2:2012cv07251 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olivia Linder
More Information Charles Linder More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: March 15, 2013 # 2:2013cv05241 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Orpha White
More Information |
Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, Inc., LLC, Ethicon | Filed: March 08, 2013 # 2:2013cv04775 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ora L. Tatum
More Information |
LLC, Ethicon, Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, Inc. | Filed: March 06, 2013 # 2:2013cv04323 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oren Aldridge
More Information Dana Aldridge More Information |
Inc., Tissue Science Laboratories Limited, C. R. Bard | Filed: March 06, 2013 # 2:2013cv04366 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olies Broussard
More Information Madonna Broussard More Information |
Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, Inc. | Filed: March 01, 2013 # 2:2013cv03983 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olivia Gonzaba
More Information Marco Gonzaba More Information |
Inc., Endo Pharmaceuticals, Endo Health Inc., Solutions Inc., American Medical Systems Holdings, American Medical Systems, Inc. | Filed: February 27, 2013 # 2:2013cv03655 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Osie Russell-Jones
More Information |
Boston Scientific Corporation | Filed: September 21, 2012 # 2:2012cv05733 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Otto Mullins
More Information Bobbi Mullins More Information |
Inc., Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon | Filed: February 14, 2013 # 2:2013cv02695 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ora Haines
More Information |
Inc., LLC, Ethicon, Boston Scientific Johnson Corporation, & Johnson, Ethicon | Filed: December 20, 2012 # 2:2012cv09420 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olivia B. Amado
More Information |
Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon, Ethicon, LLC, Inc. | Filed: December 13, 2012 # 2:2012cv08918 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oma J. Moore
More Information |
Inc., Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Endo Health Solutions Inc., American Medical Systems Holdings, Inc., American Medical Systems | Filed: December 14, 2012 # 2:2012cv08974 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Orelia Banks
More Information |
Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson, Inc. | Filed: July 18, 2012 # 2:2012cv03441 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ola Delorious Guillory
More Information |
American Medical Systems, Inc., Inc., American Medical Systems Holdings, Inc., Johnson & Johnson, Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc., LLC, Ethicon, Ethicon, Endo Health Solutions Inc. | Filed: October 09, 2012 # 2:2012cv06385 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Odis Darrell Leatherwood
More Information Kathryn Leatherwood More Information |
Tissue Science Laboratories Limited, C. R. Bard, Inc. | Filed: August 31, 2012 # 2:2012cv05022 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ossie Blackston
More Information John Blackston More Information |
Urology, Inc., Ethicon Women's Health, Inc., Gynecare, Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson | Filed: May 11, 2012 # 2:2012cv01493 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ortha Vanderpool
More Information |
Johnson & Johnson, Ethicon, Ethicon, LLC, Inc. | Filed: August 06, 2012 # 2:2012cv04087 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ora Rose
More Information Preston Rose More Information |
Inc., Inc., Ethicon, Johnson & Johnson | Filed: July 30, 2012 # 2:2012cv03796 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Oscar Roman
More Information Carmen I. Roman More Information |
Inc., C. R. Bard, Sofradim Production SAS | Filed: May 04, 2012 # 2:2012cv01424 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ottmer Paxton
More Information Jerry Dale Chandler More Information |
RSCR West Virginia, Southern Home Care Services, , Anna Beavers, Inc., Inc., Inc., Res-Care | Filed: February 24, 2011 # 2:2011cv00124 - Personal Injury- Medical Malpractice §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Orathai Glasser
More Information Scott Glasser More Information |
UDL Laboratories, Inc., Mylan Pharmaceuticals, Actavis, Roe Corporations I - X, Walgreen Co., Inc., Does I - X, Inc., Actavis Totowa, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., LLC | Filed: July 16, 2010 # 2:2010cv00918 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwin |
|
Ola Harris
More Information |
Inc., Actavis Elizabeth, Mylan Laboratories, Inc., LLC, Inc., Mylan, Actavis Inc., Actavis Totowa, LLC, Mylan Bertek Pharmaceuticals | Filed: April 23, 2010 # 2:2010cv00569 - Personal Injury- Product Liability §28:1332 jury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olen Eaton
More Information |
Inc., Actavis Totowa, Mylan Bertek Inc., Pharmaceuticals Mylan, Inc., Actavis Inc., Actavis Elizabeth, UDL Laboratories, Mylan Pharmaceuticals, LLC, LLC, Inc. | Filed: March 23, 2010 # 2:2010cv00385 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ollie Jernagin
More Information Ingrid Jernagin More Information |
Inc., Inc., UDL Laboratories, Mylan Actavis Pharmaceuticals, Totowa, Actavis Elizabeth, Mylan, LLC, Actavis Inc., LLC, Inc., Mylan Bertek Pharmaceuticals Inc. | Filed: March 02, 2010 # 2:2010cv00212 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: jury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Opal Morrison
More Information Wade Morrison More Information |
Inc., Big Lots Stores | Filed: September 22, 2009 # 3:2009cv01022 - None §28:1332 Diversity-Persona Judge: |
|
Ortra Wayne Davis
More Information |
Inc., Mylan Pharmaceuticals, LLC, Inc., Mylan Bertek Pharmaceuticals Inc., Mylan, UDL Laboratories, Actavis Inc., Inc., LLC, Actavis Elizabeth, Actavis Totowa | Filed: April 27, 2009 # 2:2009cv00460 - Plaintiff §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: jury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Octavius Spann
More Information |
Inc., Dependable Rolloffs, Ernest Webb | Filed: February 11, 2009 # 3:2009cv00125 - Both §Diversity Judge: jury demanded by 28:1332 Diversity-Tort/Motor Vehicle (P.I.) |
|
Oscar Lee Taylor
More Information |
Experian, Inc. | Filed: January 13, 2009 # 1:2008cv00207 - Plaintiff §Diversity Judge: Irene M Keeleyjury demanded by 15:1681 Fair Credit Reporting Act |
|
Olin McClanahan
More Information |
LLC, Akzo Chemicals, Apogee Coal Company, Flexsys America L.P., Pharmacia Corporation, Akzo Nobel Chemicals Inc., Inc., Monsanto Company, Flexsys America Co. | Filed: November 21, 2008 # 3:2008cv01334 - Both §Diversity Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by 28:1441 Petition for Removal- Product Liability |
|
Orlando D. Davis
More Information |
Southern Regional Jail | Filed: September 20, 2017 # 5:2017cv04009 - Other Civil Rights §42:1983 Judge: Irene C. Berger |
|
Othello Thomas Byndon
More Information |
Garrett Pugh, Doug Howell, The City of Wheeling | Filed: June 27, 2016 # 5:2016cv00103 - Other Civil Rights §42:1983 Judge: Frederick P. Stampjury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Olley Strong
More Information |
James Smith, Mark Cottrill, Megan J. Brennan, Eric Grossa | Filed: June 27, 2016 # 1:2016cv00140 - Other Civil Rights §28:1331 Judge: Irene M. Keeley |
|
Ohio Valley Banc Corp.
More Information |
Lodestone Banking Consultancy, Inc. | Filed: October 08, 2020 # 2:2020cv00660 - Contract: Other §28:1332 |
|
Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition
More Information |
Inc., JMAC Leasing | Filed: January 21, 2021 # 2:2021cv00057 - Constitutional - State Statute §77:7777 |
|
Ohio Valley Physicians
More Information |
Commonwealth Billing, LLC | Filed: February 05, 2021 # 3:2021cv00094 - Contract: Other §28:1332 jury demanded by Plaintiff |
|
Ohio Valley Physicians
More Information |
Human Resources, West Virginia Bureau for West Medical Services, Virginia Department of Health, Bill Crouch, Unicare Health Plan of West Virginia, Inc., Tadd Haynes, Cindy Beane | Filed: August 19, 2021 # 2:2021cv00462 - Other Statutory Actions §28:1441 jury demanded by Plaintiff |