West Virginia Lawyers Directory
Instant Court Records Search
Criminal Court Records, Civil Court Records, Traffic Court Records
Federal, State, County & Municipal Sources and Much More!
Search for Cases from January 19, 1972 to July 13, 2022
A (4476 rec) B (4869 rec) C (7339 rec) D (7594 rec) E (3021 rec) F (1110 rec) G (2473 rec) H (1343 rec) I (567 rec) J (9331 rec) K (4265 rec) L (6030 rec) M (8343 rec) N (1727 rec) O (378 rec) P (3887 rec) Q (19 rec) R (6071 rec) S (7268 rec) T (4873 rec) U (413 rec) V (1659 rec) W (1872 rec) X (9 rec) Y (254 rec) Z (99 rec) Plaintiff / Defendant Name |
Petitioner / Respondent Name |
Filed, Nature of Suit, Judge |
---|---|---|
Brian Northcraft
More Information |
West Virginia Division of Corrections, Rehabilitation | Filed: February 03, 2020 # 2:2020cv00100 - Civil Shell Case Opening §77:7777 |
Byron Meeks
More Information |
Rob McClung, Joe Martin, Tom Joyce | Filed: November 27, 2019 # 2:2019cv00846 - Racketeer/Corrupt Organization §18:1961 Judge: John T Copenhaver, Dwane L Tinsley |
Byron Meeks
More Information |
Joe Martin, Rob McClung, Tom Joyce | Filed: July 31, 2019 # 1:2019cv00144 - Racketeer/Corrupt Organization §18:1961 Judge: Michael John Aloi, Irene M Keeley |
Brandon Adkins
More Information Traci Adkins More Information |
N.A., John Doe Entity, Wells Fargo Bank | Filed: April 12, 2019 # 3:2019cv00275 - Consumer Credit §47:0227 |
Bobbi J. Riddle
More Information |
LC, Atkins & Ogle Law Offices | Filed: April 04, 2019 # 3:2019cv00249 - Civil Shell Case Opening §77:7777 |
Barbara Gower
More Information Terry Gower More Information |
LLC, Ocwen Loan Servicing | Filed: February 28, 2019 # 2:2019cv00020 - Consumer Credit §28:1332 Judge: Thomas S Kleehjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brian Reilly
More Information Jessica Reilly More Information |
Dynamic Recovery Solutions, LLC | Filed: February 05, 2019 # 3:2019cv00088 - Consumer Credit §47:0227 Judge: Robert C Chambersjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Bryant K. Creighton
More Information Beth Ann Creighton More Information |
Equifax Information Services, TransUnion, LLC., Experian Information Solutions, Inc., LLC | Filed: January 21, 2019 # 5:2019cv00007 - Consumer Credit §15:1681 Judge: Frederick P Stampjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Beckley Oncology Associates
More Information |
Rami Abumasmah | Filed: December 31, 2018 # 5:2018cv01549 - Other Statutes: Arbitration §28:1332 Judge: Irene C Berger |
Brian J. Lee
More Information |
LLC, Healthcare Revenue Recovery Group | Filed: November 15, 2018 # 3:2018cv00185 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: Gina M Groh |
Brenda Davis
More Information Clarence Davis More Information |
LLC, Attorney at Law, Dish Network, LLC, Maury Cobb | Filed: November 08, 2018 # 3:2018cv01415 - Consumer Credit §47:0227 Judge: Robert C Chambersjury demanded by Both |
Bryant K. Creighton
More Information Beth Ann Creighton More Information |
LLC, Inc., Diamond Resorts Financial Services, Ocean Beach Club | Filed: July 13, 2018 # 5:2018cv00116 - Consumer Credit §15:1681 Judge: Frederick P Stampjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brian Reilly
More Information Jessica Reilly More Information |
Citibank, N.A. | Filed: June 28, 2018 # 3:2018cv01094 - Consumer Credit §47:0227 Judge: Robert C Chambersjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Barbara A. Gillis
More Information Elizabeth Moats More Information |
LLC, Bayview Loan Servicing | Filed: June 04, 2018 # 2:2018cv00057 - Other Statutory Actions §28:1441 Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Branda M. Kessler
More Information |
Fay Servicing, LLC | Filed: April 02, 2018 # 2:2018cv00518 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: Thomas E. Johnstonjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Berkeley County Council
More Information |
Cephalon, LLC, Inc., Johnson & Johnson, LP, Ortho-McNeil-Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Purdue Pharmaceutical Products, Allergan Sales, Inc., Inc., The Purdue Frederick Company, Actavis Pharma, Teva Pharmaceutica, Inc., LP, Allergan USA, Inc., Purdue Pharma | Filed: November 21, 2017 # 3:2017cv00143 - Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations §18:1961 Judge: Gina M. Grohjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Boone County Commission
More Information |
Kroger Limited Partnership II, Inc., Kroger I, Limited Partnership Inc., Cardinal Health, Rite Aid of Maryland, McKesson Corporation, H.D. Smith Wholesale Drug Co., LLC, AmerisourceBergen Drug Corporation, Inc., Anda Pharmaceutical, Generics Bidco I, Anda | Filed: March 27, 2017 # 2:2017cv02028 - Other Statutory Actions §21:801 Judge: David A. Faberjury demanded by Both |
Brian Hess
More Information |
Select Management Resourses, LLC, LLC, Anderson Financial Services | Filed: September 27, 2016 # 3:2016cv00137 - Other Statutory Actions §47:227 Judge: Gina M. Groh |
Bailey Glasser
More Information |
Yukos Capital S.A.R.L. | Filed: April 20, 2016 # 2:2016mc00068 - Other §Motion to Quash Judge: Joseph R. Goodwin |
Brandy S. Hayton
More Information |
Midland Funding LLC | Filed: March 18, 2016 # 3:2016cv02639 - Consumer Credit §15:1681 Judge: Robert C. Chambersjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Bryan Anthony Reo
More Information |
Alliance Security Inc. | Filed: December 29, 2015 # 1:2015cv00238 - Other Statutory Actions §47:227 Judge: Irene M. Keeleyjury demanded by Defendant |
Beverly Enterprises-West Virginia
More Information |
Isaac D. Anderson, Mary Sue Anderson | Filed: September 01, 2015 # 2:2015cv12880 - Arbitration §09:1 Judge: Thomas E. Johnston |
Bruce A. Fernett
More Information |
P.S.C., Fenton & McGarvey Law Firm | Filed: August 14, 2015 # 2:2015cv12282 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: John T. Copenhaverjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brenda G. Harrison
More Information |
Megan Urban, PLLC, Taylor Law | Filed: July 22, 2015 # 2:2015cv11426 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: John T. Copenhaverjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brad Weekley
More Information Linda Weekley More Information |
First National Bank of Pennsylvania | Filed: January 16, 2015 # 5:2015cv00006 - Consumer Credit §28:1332 Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by Both |
Bill Garcia
More Information |
UTC Fire & Security Americas Corp., Inc. | Filed: November 05, 2014 # 1:2014cv00185 - Other Statutory Actions §47:227 Judge: Irene M. Keeleyjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Bethany West
More Information Adam West More Information |
Nationstar Mortgage, Jeffrey S. Moore, LLC | Filed: July 25, 2013 # 3:2013cv20989 - Consumer Credit §28:1332 Diversity-Fraud Judge: Robert C. Chambersjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brian Blankenship
More Information |
T.D. Ameritrade, Inc. | Filed: April 15, 2013 # 1:2013cv08048 - Securities/Commodities §28:1441 - Petition for Re Judge: R. Clarke VanDervort |
Biliki Douglas
More Information |
Mountain State University, Charles H. Polk, Mountain State University Foundation, Inc., Mountain State University Endowment Fund, Inc., Inc, Mountain State University Building Company | Filed: December 04, 2012 # 3:2012cv00148 - Racketeer/Corrupt Organization §28:1332 Diversity-Racket Judge: Gina M. Grohjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brenda Ernest
More Information Richard Ernest More Information |
Brachfeld Law Group, CitiFinancial, Inc., P.C. | Filed: August 14, 2012 # 1:2012cv04313 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: David A. Faberjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Bruce W. Hutchens
More Information Shirley Victoria Vest-Hutchens More Information |
Inc., A&N Financial Firm, West Asset Management | Filed: December 16, 2011 # 1:2011cv00996 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: David A. Faberjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Breton Lee Morgan
More Information |
Kathleen Sebelius | Filed: May 03, 2011 # 3:2011cv00300 - Other Statutory Actions §42:405 Judge: Robert C. Chambers |
Brandy Cozmyk
More Information Dorothy Cozmyk More Information Gary Cozmyk More Information Aaron Cozmyk |
Enhanced Recovery Corporation | Filed: March 25, 2011 # 2:2011cv00191 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brandy Cozmyk
More Information |
Financial Management Services, Inc. | Filed: March 24, 2011 # 2:2011cv00189 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Barry Conaty
More Information |
Urgent Care America (DEL), Matthew D. Levy, B. William Shef, Inc., The Lohman Group, Butler Consulting Group, Mountain Medical, Calvert & Company, Jeffrey A. McCandless, P.C., Renee M. Lohman, Inc., LLC, Inc., Ravih B. Masih, PLLC, Mountain Medical PC | Filed: February 16, 2011 # 2:2011cv00014 - Securities/Commodities §15:77 Securities Fraud Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by Both |
Bruce Hanshew
More Information Carolyn Hanshew More Information |
Midland Credit Management, Inc. | Filed: January 26, 2011 # 5:2011cv00064 - Consumer Credit §15:1692 Judge: Irene C. Berger |
Board of Trustees
More Information et al More Information National Stabilization Agreement of the Sheet Metal Industry Trust Fund |
Ferguson Brothers Heating & Plumbing Company | Filed: September 29, 2010 # 3:2010mc00114 - Other Statutory Actions §Registration of Foreign J |
Bradley H. Brown
More Information |
Michael J. Astrue | Filed: September 28, 2010 # 2:2010cv01147 - Other §77:7777 |
Brian D. Elliott
More Information Shannon White More Information |
1st Financial Bank USA | Filed: August 31, 2010 # 5:2010cv00088 - Consumer Credit §28:1332 Judge: Frederick P. Stampjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Beneta Bates
More Information Kevin Bates More Information |
HSBC Mortgage Services Inc., Equifirst John Doe Corporation, Holder | Filed: August 25, 2010 # 1:2010cv00132 - Consumer Credit §28:1441 Judge: Irene M. Keeleyjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brandon W. Clabaugh
More Information Rebecca L. Clabaugh More Information |
Inc., Green Tree Servicing, John Doe Holder, National City Mortgage, LLC | Filed: August 11, 2010 # 2:2010cv01015 - Consumer Credit §28:1332 jury demanded by Plaintiff |
Bobby Bragg
More Information |
American Optical Corporation | Filed: August 06, 2010 # 2:2010cv00995 - Other §77:7777 |
Betty A. Evans
More Information |
LLC, Trans Union | Filed: July 22, 2010 # 2:2010cv00945 - Other §77:7777 |
Billy Joe Querry
More Information |
LLC, Fola Coal Company | Filed: July 15, 2010 # 2:2010cv00912 - Other §77:7777 |
Bonnie Dempsey
More Information |
Baxter International, Inc. | Filed: July 08, 2010 # 2:2010cv00889 - Other §77:7777 |
Bannar C. Catlett
More Information |
David Ballard | Filed: June 21, 2010 # 2:2010cv00850 - Other §77:7777 |
Branch Banking & Trust Company
More Information |
Retta Sims | Filed: April 28, 2010 # 3:2010cv00051 - Consumer Credit §28:1332 Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by Defendant |
Brenda Woodward
More Information |
Actavis Totowa, LLC | Filed: April 24, 2010 # 2:2010cv00646 - Other §77:7777 |
Billy Boyd
More Information |
Digitek Products Liability Litigation | Filed: April 26, 2010 # 2:2010cv00613 - Other §77:7777 |
Barbara Harvin
More Information |
LLC, Actavis Totowa | Filed: April 24, 2010 # 2:2010cv00651 - Other §77:7777 |
Barbara McCauley
More Information |
Actavis Totowa, LLC | Filed: April 23, 2010 # 2:2010cv00593 - Other §77:7777 |
Bobby Watkins
More Information |
Inc., Mylan Pharmaceuticals | Filed: April 22, 2010 # 2:2010cv00561 - Other §77:7777 |
Barbara Winkler
More Information |
Antonio Russell | Filed: April 21, 2010 # 2:2010cv00542 - Other §77:7777 |
Beverly Ann Mullins
More Information |
Inc., John W. Clark Oil Company | Filed: April 21, 2010 # 2:2010cv00547 - Other §77:7777 |
Betty J. Baker
More Information |
LLC, Actavis Totowa | Filed: April 12, 2010 # 2:2010cv00475 - Other §77:7777 |
Betsy Bartlett
More Information |
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service | Filed: March 16, 2010 # 3:2010cv00016 - Taxes: Customer Challenge §26:7429 IRS: Tax Jeopardy Judge: John Preston Bailey |
Bob Yoak
More Information Bob Yoak Ford More Information |
Paul Astorg, Inc., Astorg Motor Company | Filed: March 08, 2010 # 6:2010cv00264 - Constitutional - State Statute §28:1331 Fed. Question Judge: jury demanded by Plaintiff |
Betty Tyson
More Information |
Monsanto Company, Flexsys America Co., Solutia Inc., Pharmacia Corporation, Apogee Coal Company, LLC, Flexsys America L.P. | Filed: December 16, 2009 # 3:2009cv01491 - Both §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Both |
Barbara Muck
More Information |
Flexsys America Co., Solutia Inc., Pharmacia Corporation, Monsanto Company, Apogee Coal Company, Flexsys America L.P., LLC | Filed: December 16, 2009 # 3:2009cv01458 - Both §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Both |
Bessie Roberts
More Information |
Solutia Inc., Apogee Coal Company, Pharmacia Corporation, Flexsys America Co., LLC, Flexsys America L.P., Monsanto Company | Filed: December 16, 2009 # 3:2009cv01485 - Both §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Both |
Baaron Lewis
More Information |
Solutia Inc., Monsanto Company, Flexsys America L.P., LLC, Apogee Coal Company, Pharmacia Corporation, Flexsys America Co. | Filed: December 15, 2009 # 3:2009cv01417 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Both |
Bessie Roberts
More Information Charles Roberts More Information |
Flexsys America Co., LLC, Pharmacia Solutia Corporation, Inc., Apogee Coal Company, Monsanto Company, Flexsys America L.P. | Filed: December 16, 2009 # 3:2009cv01456 - Both §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Both |
Blanche Mace
More Information |
LLC, Solutia Inc., Flexsys America L.P., Coal Apogee Company, Pharmacia Corporation, Monsanto Company, Flexsys America Co. | Filed: December 15, 2009 # 3:2009cv01398 - Personal Inj. Prod. Liability §28:1332 Diversity-Product Judge: Joseph R. Goodwinjury demanded by Both |
Bonnie R. Jepson
More Information |
LLC, Actavis Totowa | Filed: November 09, 2009 # 2:2009cv01231 - None §77:7777 Civil Shell Case Judge: |
Basciani Foods
More Information The Horton Fruit Co. More Information |
Carolyn A. Roy, C. Randall Blatt, Inc., Roy Enterprises | Filed: October 28, 2009 # 3:2009cv01182 - None §07:499 Agricultural Commo Judge: |
Barbara Shaffer
More Information |
Inc, National Enterprise Systems | Filed: October 27, 2009 # 1:2009cv00145 - None §28:1446 Notice of Removal Judge: Irene M. Keeley |
Billy R. Brown
More Information |
Michael H. Holland | Filed: October 23, 2009 # 5:2009cv01166 - None §77:7777 Civil Shell Case Judge: |
Breton Lee Morgan
More Information MD More Information |
Kathleen Sebelius | Filed: September 29, 2009 # 3:2009cv01059 - None §42:1320(d) Health Insuran Judge: |
Belinda Heller
More Information |
Actavis Totowa, LLC | Filed: September 25, 2009 # 2:2009cv01036 - None §77:7777 Civil Shell Case Judge: |
Barry D. Schmehl
More Information Christopher Schmehl More Information |
Franklin Credit Management Corporation | Filed: September 25, 2009 # 3:2009cv00066 - Plaintiff §28:1332 Diversity-Other C Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Beverly A. Cain
More Information |
LLC, Actavis Totowa | Filed: August 13, 2009 # 2:2009cv00929 - None §77:7777 Civil Shell Case Judge: |
Brandon Scott Blackmon
More Information |
David Ballard | Filed: July 08, 2009 # 2:2009cv00789 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: Mary E. Stanley |
Betty Jean Ortego
More Information |
LLC, Actavis Totowa | Filed: June 19, 2009 # 2:2009cv00699 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: |
Billie Jean Marshall
More Information |
Michael J. Astrue | Filed: June 19, 2009 # 5:2009cv00696 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: |
Bonita Campbell
More Information |
C. R. Bard, Inc. | Filed: June 17, 2009 # 3:2009cv00683 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: |
Benjamin Harris
More Information |
LLC, Actavis Totowa | Filed: May 22, 2009 # 2:2009cv00578 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: |
Barry Toppins
More Information |
The CIT Group/Consumer Finance, Inc. | Filed: May 08, 2009 # 2:2009cv00509 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: |
Brandy Thomas
More Information |
National Alliance on Mental Health West Virginia | Filed: May 06, 2009 # 2:2009cv00494 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: |
Bay State Truck & Trailer
More Information |
Inc., Covenant Transport | Filed: May 04, 2009 # 3:2009cv00031 - Defendant §28:1331 Fed. Question Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by Defendant |
Betty Stevens
More Information Richard Stevens More Information |
Inc., SRA Assoicates, Chrysler Financial, MRS Inc., Associates | Filed: April 24, 2009 # 1:2009cv00053 - None §15:1692 Fair Debt Collect Judge: |
Beulah Stephens
More Information Albert Stephens More Information |
Inc., C. R. Bard | Filed: May 11, 2009 # 3:2009cv00529 - None §99:9999 Report cause code Judge: |
Boilermaker-Blacksmith National Pension Fund
More Information |
Electric Motor Service Co. | Filed: April 21, 2009 # 2:2009mc00063 - Other §Registration of Foreign J Judge: jury demanded by Registration of Foreign Judgment |
Brandon Walters
More Information Jennifer Walters More Information |
LLC, Inc., Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., Netflix, Walmart.Com USA | Filed: February 09, 2009 # 2:2009cv00110 - Plaintiff §Federal Question Judge: jury demanded by 15:1 Antitrust Litigation |
Bruce Marcum
More Information |
State of West Virginia | Filed: May 28, 2008 # 2:2008cv00064 - None §Federal Question Judge: Robert E. Maxwelljury demanded by 28:1331 Fed. Question |
Brian Cole
More Information |
National Enterprise Systems, CITI BANK | Filed: April 18, 2008 # 3:2008cv00075 - Plaintiff §Diversity Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by 28:1332 Diversity-Breach of Contract |
Bricklayers
More Information Construction Industry Health More Information Trowel Trades International Pension Fund, Welfare Trust, Bricklayers Local Union No. 9 Group |
Joshua A. Hoffman, Philip G. Arthur | Filed: February 22, 2008 # 2:2008mc00021 - Other §Registration of Foreign J Judge: |
Brenda Nollge
More Information |
NA, JP Morgan Chase Bank, Emmanuel B. Loucas, Ocwen Loan Servicing, LLC | Filed: January 17, 2008 # 3:2008cv00043 - Other Statutory Actions §28:1441 Notice of Removal Judge: jury demanded by Plaintiff |
BlueHippo Funding
More Information BlueHippo Capital More Information L.L.C. More Information |
James Robert Alsop, Darrell V. McGraw‚ Jr. | Filed: June 25, 2007 # 2:2007cv00399 - Constitutional - State Statute §28:2201 Declaratory Judge Judge: |
Bernard Godby
More Information Wanda Godby More Information |
Estate of June Midkiff‚ Jr., Audrey Midkiff | Filed: May 08, 1972 # 3:1972cv02976 - Other §99:9999 Judge: Dennis R. Knapp |
Bank of America
More Information N.A. More Information |
Mona L. Wilson, United States Department of of Agriculture, United States America/Farmers Home Administration | Filed: July 12, 2019 # 5:2019cv00215 - Real Property: Other §28:1442 Judge: John Preston Bailey |
Brenda Botkin
More Information Kelly Jo Young More Information |
FSB, LLC, Wilmington Savings Fund Society, Carrington Mortgage Services | Filed: May 17, 2019 # 2:2019cv00391 - Real Property: Other §28:1441 jury demanded by Plaintiff |
Brenda Mason
More Information |
LLC, Comcast of Virginia California/Maryland/Pennsylvania/Virginia/West | Filed: March 04, 2019 # 3:2019cv00031 - Torts to Land §28:1332 Judge: Gina M Grohjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Betty Meadows
More Information |
TransCanada Power Corp., Columbia Gas LLC Transmission, | Filed: December 05, 2019 # 3:2019cv00859 - Torts to Land §28:1331 Judge: Robert C Chambersjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Betty Virginia Brown
More Information |
DREW HOLDINGS, Ditech Financial LLC, LLC | Filed: May 03, 2018 # 3:2018cv00066 - Foreclosure §28:1332 Judge: Gina M. Grohjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Barbara Jo Hinzman
More Information Clara Jane Hendrickson More Information Sharon Kay Dean |
Antero Resources Corporation | Filed: May 11, 2018 # 1:2018cv00111 - All Other Real Property §28:1441 Judge: Irene M. Keeley |
Bounty Minerals
More Information |
EQT Production Company | Filed: December 18, 2017 # 1:2017cv00219 - All Other Real Property §28:1441 Judge: Irene M. Keeleyjury demanded by Both |
Bounty Minerals
More Information |
EQT Production Company | Filed: December 18, 2017 # 1:2017cv00220 - All Other Real Property §28:1441 Judge: Irene M. Keeleyjury demanded by Both |
Brian K. Hoban
More Information |
Everpower Wind Holdings, LLC, Enbridge LLC, Holdings, Inc. (Everpower), New Creek Wind | Filed: March 04, 2017 # 2:2017cv00028 - Torts to Land §28:1332 Judge: John Preston Baileyjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Bison Resources Corporation
More Information |
Antero Resources Appalachian Corporation, Antero Resources Corporation | Filed: June 03, 2016 # 1:2016cv00107 - All Other Real Property §28:1441 Judge: Frederick P. Stampjury demanded by Plaintiff |
Branch Banking
More Information Trust Company More Information |
Unknown Occupants, Becky Ellenbogen | Filed: May 19, 2016 # 1:2016cv00094 - Foreclosure §28:1441 Judge: Irene M. Keeleyjury demanded by Defendant |