This search feature provides access to information.

Case Search California (CA)


Instant Court Records Search
Criminal Court Records, Civil Court Records, Traffic Court Records
Federal, State, County & Municipal Sources and Much More!

Participant Index
Aliet-Gass, Ingrid
BANKS, FREDERICK
BEHLER, KORRI
BOOBYYAA, MANDINGO
BOOMER, RODNEY
BROOKS, CHARLES
BROWN, DARRELL
BUTLER, KIMBERLY
Bar, Santa
Brown, Jackie
CAMPBELL, KEVIN
CAREY, HENRY
CARTY, JENNIFER
CECCHI, CLAIRE
CHANEY, MADISON
COLLINS, DEPUTY
CONNOR, FRANKLIN
CONNOR, IVINS
COTTON, RICHARD
Carter, Ashton
Collier, Mnemosyne
Coordinator, Grievance
Cortez, Annabelle
DAMITER, P.
DEMELLO, ROBERT
DEMMING, WINSTON
DICKSON, JONATHAN
DOSSIE, RICKEY
Edison, Southern
El, Ituok
FAGON, HENRY
FORBES, COREY
FORBES, EDWILL
FRANCIS, JULIO
FRANICS, ALVIN
FREDERICK, CECIL
FREDERICK, DAVID
Frakes, Scott
GENERAL, ATTORNEY
GILLMAN, ROBERT
GROSSMAN, SHIRLEY
Gas, Riverwood
Gazsi, Tom
Golden, John
HARVEY, CARLTON
HENRY, ALVIN
HOTELS, STARWOOD
Hatch, Tom
Henderson, Denise
Henderson, Jacora
Huff, Ivy
Inst, Grafton
JACKMAN, DONALD
JOHNSON, BOBBY
Johnson, Jay
Kiff, Dave
LETTSOME, FREDDY
Leon, Ira
Little, Latayqa
Lowenberg, Ron
MATHIS, SHANDA
MCKEE, CHIEF
MCKEE, KENNETH
MILLER, ANTHONY
Manager, Facility
Manager, Unit
McCurn, Imani
Melcher, in
Mood, Ivin
OBERWISE, EDWARD
Oil, Phoenix
Olivas, Officer
PENNSYLVANIA, ATTORNEY
PERRY, GRADY
POLANCO-CABRERA, VICTOR
POTTER, ISAAC
PRESLEY, MARCUS
Pallas, Officer
Patterson, Akil
RASHID, KWANE
Richardson, John
SANCHEZ, IGNACIO
SCHUNEMAN, LARRY
SCOTT, ISSAC
SIMANDLE, JEROME
SMITH, RODNEY
SPELLMAN, LONNIE
Salmond, Craig
Santoro, Kelly
Segovia, Isai
Sharpnack, Rob
Shepherd, Michelle
Smith, Officer
TAYLOR, IATONDA
THROWAY, C/O
TUCKER, MATTHEW
Townsend, William
Tritz, Irene
Tritz, Richard
VALEZ, JENNIFER
W, WILLIE
WALKER, ANTHONY
Walton, Stephanie
Williams, Warren
situated, all
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: EDDIE KAY COPEMANUNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-7068], [Filed: October 16, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
California,   October 23, 2015
Case 1:2015cv01643/287447
US District Court for the Eastern District of California case 1:2015cv01643/287447 comprises Inviron Technologies, Inc. and Western States International, Inc., Ingrid Aliet-Gass, United Pacific Energy Corporation, Tearlach Resources LTD., United Pacific Energy Operations And Consulting, Inc., Phoenix Oil and Gas Inc., Riverwood Energy, LLC, Riverwood Gas and Oil LLC, Santa Bar. Filed on October 23, 2015, this case concerns Other Contract based on 28 U.S.C. § 1332. Judge Lawrence J. O'Neill, Jennifer L. Thurston is overseeing the case, and there is no demand for a jury trial.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Ingrid Aliet-Gass, ᐅ Phoenix Oil, ᐅ Riverwood Gas, ᐅ Santa Bar 
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
Ira R. Leon
More Information
State of Nebraska and Scott Frakes, Director of the Nebraska Department of Corrections
[Case # 15-3314], [Filed: October 16, 2015]
[ Habeas Corpus§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ Scott Frakes >>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
J M SMITH CORP on behalf of itself and all others similarly situated doing business as Smith Drug Company MEIJER INC MEIJER DISTRIBUTION INC ROCHESTER DRUG COOPERATIVE INC on behalf of itself and all others similarly situated STEPHEN L LAFRANCE HOLDCEPHALON INC, TEVA PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRIES LTD, TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA INC and BARR PHARMACEUTICALS INC, FKA Barr Laboratories Inc, MYLAN LABORATORIES INC, RANBAXY LABORATORIES LTD, RANBAXY PHARMACEUTICALS INC and MYLAN PHARMACEUTICALS INC
[Case # 15-3475], [Filed: October 16, 2015]
[ Antitrust§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
California,   October 29, 2015
Case 4:2015cv04973/292419
In the US District Court for the Northern District of California case 4:2015cv04973/292419, I.A., Craig Salmond and C.S. files a suit against City of Emeryville, Michelle Shepherd, Warren Williams, Jacora Henderson, Denise Henderson, Joshua and Sheree. The filing date was October 29, 2015, and this case concerns Other Civil Rights under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Presiding over the case is Judge Donna M. Ryu. Both have requested a jury trial.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Craig Salmond, ᐅ Michelle Shepherd, ᐅ Warren Williams, ᐅ Jacora Henderson, ᐅ Denise Henderson 
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: ANTHONY MILLER
More Information
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-2735], [Filed: July 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   DefendantRespondent
In re: LONNIE SPELLMAN
More Information
SECRETARY PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, DEPUTY COLLINS, SUPERINTENDENT, Facility Manager, MR. EVANS, Unit Manager, SUPERINTENDENT FRACKVILLE SCI, DSFM DERFLER, DSCS KOVALCHIK, P. DAMITER, Grievance Coordinator, LT. LUKASHEWSKI, C/O 1 THROWAY, B
[Case # 15-2748], [Filed: July 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ DEPUTY COLLINS, ᐅ Facility Manager, ᐅ Unit Manager, ᐅ P. DAMITER, ᐅ Grievance Coordinator, ᐅ C/O THROWAY >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: JEFFREY DARRELL HILLATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF FLORIDA
[Case # 15-13302], [Filed: July 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
California,   July 22, 2015
Case 8:2015cv01154/623637
A legal case marked by the docket number case 8:2015cv01154/623637 was filed on July 22, 2015. It involves Ivin Mood as the plaintiff and City of Costa Mesa, City of Newport Beach, Tom Gazsi, Tom Hatch, Jay Johnson, Dave Kiff, Ron Lowenberg, Officer Olivas, Officer Pallas, Officer Selinski #P450, Officer Smith and Rob Sharpnack as the defendant. The nature of the suit pertains to Civil Rights: Other, falling under the jurisdiction of US District Court for the Central District of California, presided over by Judge Kenly Kiya Kato, Margaret M. Morrow.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Ivin Mood, ᐅ Tom Gazsi, ᐅ Tom Hatch, ᐅ Jay Johnson, ᐅ Dave Kiff, ᐅ Ron Lowenberg, ᐅ Officer Olivas, ᐅ Officer Pallas, ᐅ Officer Smith, ᐅ Rob Sharpnack 
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
ISSAC SCOTT
More Information
GRADY PERRY, Warden
[Case # 15-6199], [Filed: October 29, 2015]
[ Prisoner: Habeas Corpus§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ GRADY PERRY >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: EDWARD OBERWISE
More Information
ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF FLORIDA
[Case # 15-14852], [Filed: October 29, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: ANTHONY WAYNE WALKER
More Information
II
ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF FLORIDA
[Case # 15-13301], [Filed: July 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
ISRAEL RUIZKIMBERLY BUTLER, Warden
[Case # 15-2818], [Filed: August 25, 2015]
[ Habeas Corpus§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ KIMBERLY BUTLER >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: MARK DUKEATTORNEY GENERAL STATE OF ALABAMA
[Case # 15-13803], [Filed: August 25, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: BORN ISLAM RUSHNOEL L. HILLMAN
[Case # 15-3029], [Filed: August 25, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: MARCUS PRESLEY
More Information
ATTORNEY GENERAL STATE OF ALABAMA
[Case # 15-13802], [Filed: August 25, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
California,   August 25, 2015
Case 2:2015cv06465/626288
Alright, here we have International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 47, AFL-CIO versus Does and Southern California Edison. Case number case 2:2015cv06465/626288, started on August 25, 2015. This is all about Labor: Labor/Mgt. Relations before Judge Alicia G. Rosenberg, Christina A. Snyder.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Southern California Edison 
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: RODNEY SMITH
More Information
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-2977], [Filed: August 25, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
ISAAC A. POTTER
More Information
JR.
LINCOLN HERITAGE LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, GERBER LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, LIFE OF BOSTON INSURANCE COMPANY, GERBER PRODUCTS COMPANY, SHIRLEY GROSSMAN, LARRY SCHUNEMAN, KORRI BEHLER, ALAN STACHURA, NESTLE HOLDING INC. and THE CORPORATION TRUST COMPANY
[Case # 15-14843], [Filed: October 29, 2015]
[ Insurance§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ SHIRLEY GROSSMAN, ᐅ LARRY SCHUNEMAN, ᐅ KORRI BEHLER >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
Isai Segovia
More Information
Kelly Santoro
[Case # 2015cv08476/631659], [Filed: October 29, 2015]
[ Habeas Corpus (General)§ ⚖ ]
[Judge: Andre Birotte, Rozella A. Oliver]
ᐅ Kelly Santoro >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: VICTOR POLANCO-CABRERA
More Information
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-14901], [Filed: October 30, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
California,   October 30, 2015
Case 2:2015cv02253/287497
At the US District Court for the Eastern District of California, the legal case 2:2015cv02253/287497 involves Ivy Huff, John Golden, Latayqa Little, Jackie Brown, Mnemosyne Collier, Stephanie Walton, Akil Patterson and William Townsend and UniRush, LLC, Rush Communications, LLC, Rush Communications of NYC, Inc., MetaBank, Meta Financial Group, Inc. and MasterCard Inc. Filed on October 30, 2015, this case deals with Other Fraud based on 28 U.S.C. § 1332. Judge Craig M. Kellison, Kimberly J. Mueller is overseeing the proceedings, and it's worth noting that the Plaintiff has requested a jury trial.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Ivy Huff, ᐅ John Golden, ᐅ Latayqa Little, ᐅ Jackie Brown, ᐅ Mnemosyne Collier, ᐅ Stephanie Walton, ᐅ Akil Patterson, ᐅ William Townsend 
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: WILLIE DREWATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF GEORGIA
[Case # 15-14879], [Filed: October 30, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: DARRELL E. BROWN
More Information
ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF GEORGIA
[Case # 15-14877], [Filed: October 30, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: BOBBY L. JOHNSON
More Information
ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF FLORIDA
[Case # 15-14881], [Filed: October 30, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
In re: MATTHEW TUCKER
More Information
JEROME B. SIMANDLE, CLERK UNITED STATES DISTRIC COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY, STATE OF NEW JERSEY, JENNIFER VALEZ, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, ATTORNEY GENERAL NEW JERSEY and GOVERNOR OF NEW JERSEY
[Case # 14-4720], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ JEROME B. SIMANDLE, ᐅ JENNIFER VALEZ >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: ROBERT J. DEMELLO
More Information
JR.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 14-15687], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: RODNEY BOOMER
More Information
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
[Case # 14-4740], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: JUAN DIAZ-GONZALEZATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF FLORIDA
[Case # 14-15584], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: JAMAAL ALI BILALATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF FLORIDA and UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 14-15611], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
California,   December 15, 2014
Case 3:2014cv02952/461374
At the US District Court for the Southern District of California, the legal case 3:2014cv02952/461374 involves 5.11, Inc. and SOG Specialty Knives and Tools, LLC and Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Filed on December 15, 2014, this case deals with Trademark based on 15 U.S.C. § 1114. Judge William V. Gallo, Janis L. Sammartino is overseeing the proceedings, and it's worth noting that the Defendant has requested a jury trial.
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
In re: RICHARD COTTON
More Information
DISTRICT ATTORNEY ALLEGHENY COUNTY
[Case # 14-4725], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
KEVIN CAMPBELL
More Information
HENRY CAREY
More Information
JENNIFER CARTY
More Information
IVINS CONNOR
More Information
FRANKLIN CONNOR
More Information
WINSTON DEMMING
More Information
HENRY FAGON
More Information
COREY FORBES
More Information
JULIO FRANCIS
More Information
III EDWILL FORBES
More Information
ALVIN FRANICS
More Information
CECIL FREDERICK
More Information
DAVID FREDERICK
More Information
CARLTON HARVEY
More Information
ALVIN HENRY
More Information
RAED M. HUSSEIN JOSEP
RITZ CARLTON VI, WINDRIDGE INC, DBA Windspree, VI PORT AUTHORITY, WHEATLEY TAXI SERVICE AND TOURS, EAST END OPERATIONS INC, DBA East End Taxi Association, ALEX BORDEAUX, FREDDY LETTSOME, DBA Dynamic Tours, CANEEL BAY INC, KELLY TOURS INC, STARWOOD HOTELS
[Case # 15-3497], [Filed: October 22, 2015]
[ Civil (Rico)§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ FREDDY LETTSOME, ᐅ STARWOOD HOTELS >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: ROBERT WAYNE GILLMAN
More Information
ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF FLORIDA
[Case # 15-14723], [Filed: October 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: MADJIED ALI SAMOEDIENUNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-14882], [Filed: October 30, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: MATTHEW TUCKER
More Information
CHIEF JUDGE THEODORE A. MCKEE, STATE OF NEW JERSEY, JENNIFER VALEZ and ATTORNEY GENERAL NEW JERSEY, JOHN HOFFMAN, CLAIRE C. CECCHI
[Case # 15-3546], [Filed: October 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ CHIEF JUDGE THEODORE A. MCKEE, ᐅ JENNIFER VALEZ, ᐅ CLAIRE C. CECCHI >>> More Information
PlaintiffPetitioner   versus   DefendantRespondent
UNITED STATES OF AMERICATERRITORY OF VIRGIN ISLANDS
[Case # 15-3552], [Filed: October 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: JONATHAN DICKSON
More Information
TIM GLEASON
[Case # 15-4160], [Filed: October 22, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
California,   October 21, 2015
Case 2:2015cv08253/631067
We got a case, Ituok Amano El against Annabelle G. Cortez and Department of Childrens Services, you know? Case number case 2:2015cv08253/631067, started on October 21, 2015. It's about Constitutional - State Statute, being heard by Judge R. Gary Klausner, Frederick F. Mumm.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Ituok Amano El, ᐅ Annabelle G. Cortez 
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: DWIGHT E. MOSSUNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-14694], [Filed: October 21, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   DefendantRespondent
UNITED STATES OF AMERICAIn re: FREDERICK H. BANKS
[Case # 15-3518], [Filed: October 21, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ FREDERICK H. BANKS >>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   DefendantRespondent
In re: DONALD G. JACKMAN
More Information
JR.
WARDEN FORT DIX FCI
[Case # 14-4721], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
California,   December 15, 2014
Case 5:2014cv05451/283008
US District Court for the Northern District of California case 5:2014cv05451/283008 comprises in re Jacqueline C Melcher and John W. Richardson. Filed on December 15, 2014, this case concerns Appeal based on 28 U.S.C. § 0158. Judge Ronald M. Whyte is overseeing the case, and there is no demand for a jury trial.
More Information about >>> ᐅ in re Jacqueline C Melcher, ᐅ John W. Richardson 
Plaintiff   versus   DefendantRespondent
In re: RICKEY DOSSIE
More Information
SUPERINTENDENT FAYETTE SCI, DISTRICT ATTORNEY PHILADELPHIA and ATTORNEY GENERAL PENNSYLVANIA
[Case # 14-4722], [Filed: December 15, 2014]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL PENNSYLVANIA >>> More Information
California,   October 30, 2015
Case 8:2015cv01771/631856
Alright, check it—Irene C Tritz and Richard J Tritz is up against Does and The United States of America. Case number case 8:2015cv01771/631856, kicked off on October 30, 2015. It's about Taxes and it's in front of Judge Fernando M. Olguin, Suzanne H. Segal.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Irene C Tritz, ᐅ Richard J Tritz 
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: AMERICAN NATIONAL PROPERTY AND CASUALTY COMPANYMADISON CHANEY
[Case # 15-6210], [Filed: November 03, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ MADISON CHANEY >>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
SHANDA ADRAINE MATHIS
More Information
GREAT LAKES EDUCATIONAL LOAN SERVICES, INC. and CITY OF TOLEDO, DIVISION OF TAXATION
[Case # 15-8043], [Filed: November 03, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
IATONDA TAYLOR
More Information
KENNETH T. MCKEE, Warden
[Case # 15-2336], [Filed: November 03, 2015]
[ Prisoner: Habeas Corpus§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ KENNETH T. MCKEE >>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
IGNACIO SANCHEZ
More Information
WARDEN, Grafton Corr Inst
[Case # 15-4204], [Filed: November 03, 2015]
[ Prisoner: Civil Rights§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ Grafton Corr Inst >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: DON MITCHELL WILBORNUNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-15035], [Filed: November 06, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
California,   November 06, 2015
Case 2:2015cv02310/287757
At the US District Court for the Eastern District of California, the legal case 2:2015cv02310/287757 entails Imani M. McCurn and Ashton B. Carter. The filing date is November 06, 2015, and this case deals with Employment as per 29 U.S.C. § 791. Judge Carolyn K. Delaney, Troy L. Nunley is presiding over this matter, and no jury trial is demanded.
More Information about >>> ᐅ Imani M. McCurn, ᐅ Ashton B. Carter 
California,   November 06, 2015
Case 2:2015cv08678/632345
Alright, it's I3Sign Supply, Inc. taking on DCS Deals, Inc. and Does. Case number case 2:2015cv08678/632345, started on November 06, 2015. It's about Trademark and it's in front of Judge John A. Kronstadt, Alicia G. Rosenberg.
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: KWANE RASHID
More Information
ATTORNEY GENERAL, STATE OF GEORGIA
[Case # 15-14908], [Filed: November 02, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

ᐅ ATTORNEY GENERAL >>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: CHARLES AARON BROOKS
More Information
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-3628], [Filed: November 02, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Petitioner   versus   Respondent
In re: MANDINGO BOOBYYAA
More Information
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
[Case # 15-14914], [Filed: November 02, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information
Plaintiff   versus   Defendant
F BARAGANO PHARMACEUTICALS INCORTHO CLINICAL DIAGNOSTICS INC, IMMUCOR INC
[Case # 15-8108], [Filed: November 02, 2015]
[ Other§ ⚖ ]

>>> More Information


Court records are widely used for a multitude of purposes, but whatever your specific reason, their main objective is to provide information.

To put it simply, court records provide data in black and white. Ask a Lawyer

Leave a Comment