Minnesota Lawyers
Instant Court Records Search
Criminal Court Records, Civil Court Records, Traffic Court Records
Federal, State, County & Municipal Sources and Much More!
Search for Cases from September 21, 1992 to January 15, 2021
A (2410 rec) B (2140 rec) C (2978 rec) D (3310 rec) E (1322 rec) F (728 rec) G (1377 rec) H (819 rec) I (302 rec) J (4821 rec) K (1784 rec) L (2234 rec) M (3864 rec) N (855 rec) O (307 rec) P (1482 rec) Q (36 rec) R (3034 rec) S (2937 rec) T (2262 rec) U (3583 rec) V (537 rec) W (1051 rec) X (18 rec) Y (97 rec) Z (110 rec)| Plaintiff / Defendant Name |
Petitioner / Respondent Name |
Filed, Nature of Suit, Judge |
|---|---|---|
| Physeon GmbH | Covance Inc. | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2020cv00758 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Becky R Thorson, Wilhelmina M Wright, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Provitas, LLC | LLC, Quality Ingredients Corporation, DSM Nutritional Products | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2020cv00806 - Contract Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Nancy E Brasel, David T Schultz, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Portfolio Advisors VIII, LLC | James H. Booth, LLC, Southeastern Land, James H Booth, Ted McGinnis | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2020cv00690 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Hildy Bowbeer, Patrick J Schiltz |
| Peter Florczak | United States Steel Corporation | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2020cv00631 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Nancy E Brasel, Leo I Brisbois, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| PKG Contracting, Inc. | MNX, Inc. | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2020cv00742 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Nancy E Brasel, Elizabeth Cowan Wright, jury demanded by Both |
| Poultry Borderless Company, LLC | Trent Froemming, Darrin Froemming, TFC Partners, LLC | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2020cv01054 - Contract: Other §28:1332 , jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| PetroChoice, LLC | David Modeen | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2019cv02999 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Leo I Brisbois, Patrick J Schiltz, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Protege Biomedical, LLC | Duff & Phelps Securities, Philip I Smith, I. Philip Smith, LLC | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2019cv03152 - Contract: Other §28:1330 Judge: Hildy Bowbeer, John R Tunheim |
| Park Hospitality LLC | Martina Ansereo, Jaime Ansereo, Domingo Ansereo, AQ Group LLC | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2019cv02768 - Contract: Franchise §28:1332 Judge: Hildy Bowbeer, Tony N Leung |
| Presidio Networked Solutions LLC, Presidio, Inc., Presidio Holdings Inc. | Alchemy Technology Group, Lucas Marquardt, LLC | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2019cv02778 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Leo I Brisbois, Donovan W Frank |
| Plato Woodwork, Inc. | Continental Insurance Company, Valley Forge The, Insurance Company, The Continental Insurance Company | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2019cv02926 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Paul A Magnuson, Elizabeth Cowan Wright |
| Progressive Direct Insurance Company, Progressive Preferred Insurance Company | Estate of Bradley D. Stover, Casey J. Talberg | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2019cv02536 - Insurance §28:2201 Judge: Leo I Brisbois, Eric C Tostrud, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Progressive Direct Insurance Company | William Rithmiller, Jake Thompson | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2019cv02470 - Insurance §28:2201 Judge: Hildy Bowbeer, Patrick J Schiltz, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Patterson Dental Supply, Inc. | Daniele Pace | # 0:2019cv01940 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Leo I Brisbois, Joan N Ericksen, jury demanded by Both |
| Patricia Ketchum, Peter Murphy, Frank Baca, Tim Walsh, Julie Walsh, Gregory Ketchum, Cary Basnar | Frank R. Ramirez, Mick A. Occhiato, Brent M.T. Keele, Jerry Morgensen, Ryan A. Martorano, Stephen D. Tebo, Clifford M. Buchholz, Michael J. Herold, James L. Parke, Joseph D. Schofield‚ III, LLC, LLC, St. Renatus, SR Merger Sub | # 0:2019cv01856 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Hildy Bowbeer, David S Doty, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Patricia Ketchum, Peter Murphy, Frank Baca, Tim Walsh, Julie Walsh, Gregory Ketchum, Cary Basnar | Jerry Morgensen, Frank R. Ramirez, LLC, James L. Parke, Michael J. Herold, Clifford M. Buchholz, Mick A. Occhiato, Ryan A. Martorano, Brent M.T. Keele, St. Renatus, Joseph D. Schofield‚ III, SR Merger Sub, Stephen D. Tebo, LLC | # 0:2019cv01855 - Contract: Other §28:1332 , jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Patterson Dental Supply, Inc. | Daniele Pace | # 0:2019cv01915 - Contract: Other §28:1332 , jury demanded by Both |
| # 0:2019cv01493 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Nancy E Brasel, Becky R Thorson |
||
| Principal Life Insurance Company | The Estate of Jonathan E. Cummings, Jill Marie Richardson | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2019cv01451 - Insurance §28:1332 |
| Petro Siruk, Trust Capital LLC | North Mill Equipment Finance LLC, Todd Assurance Frisinger, Partners LLC, Quality Truck Care Center LLC, Erick McAllister, Paul Kendall, EFS Credit Trust | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2019cv01021 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Nancy E Brasel, Steven E Rau |
| Prospect ECHN, Inc. | Winthrop Resources Corporation | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2019cv00586 - Contract: Other §28:1330 , jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Peter M Moloney | One Off Effects LLC | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2019cv00252 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Elizabeth Cowan Wright, Wilhelmina M Wright |
| Polaris Industries Inc. | Gregory Adler | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2019cv00241 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Donovan W Frank, Katherine M Menendez, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Protege Biomedical, LLC | DW Management Services, LLC, Z-Medica, LLC | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2018cv03227 - Contract: Other § Judge: Hildy Bowbeer, John R Tunheim, jury demanded by Both |
| Patrick Bollom, Colleen Bollom | MarineMax, Inc., Brunswick Corporation | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2018cv03105 - Contract: Other §15:2301 Judge: Michael J Davis, Steven E Rau |
| Patterson Dental Supply, Inc. | PC, Touradj Ameli, Arid Newton-Wellesley | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2018cv02670 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Steven E Rau, Patrick J Schiltz, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Prime Therapeutics LLC | Maxor National Pharmacy Services, Ashley D. LLC Beatty, | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2018cv02715 - Contract: Other § Judge: Katherine M Menendez, Eric C Tostrud, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Park Hospitality LLC | Sangha Hospitality, Rupinder S. Sangha, LLC | # 0:2018cv02171 - Contract: Franchise §28:1332 Judge: Nancy E Brasel, Becky R Thorson |
| Polaris Sales Inc. | Inc., Star City Motor Sports | # 0:2018cv01716 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Katherine M. Menendez |
| Preferred Controls, Inc. | Integrated Process Solutions, Mitchell Severson, Inc., Walter Pelowski | # 0:2018cv01533 - Other Contract §18:1836 Judge: Susan Richard Nelson, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Praxair Distribution, Inc. | Irish Oxygen Company | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2018cv01321 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Wilhelmina M. Wright |
| Park Hospitality LLC | Inc., Sarbjit S. Dosanjh, Brady Hotel | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2018cv01205 - Franchise §28:1332 Judge: Becky R. Thorson |
| Platinum Bank | Security National Insurance Company | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2018cv01142 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Katherine M. Menendez, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Pedro J. Becquer | Marque Teegardin, Inc., Mirantis | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2018cv01072 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: David S. Doty, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Physician Specialty Pharmacy, LLC | LLC, Prime Therapeutics | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2018cv01044 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Tony N. Leung, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Pioneer Plastics, Inc. | J & J Solutions, Inc. | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2018cv00753 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Becky R. Thorson, jury demanded by Defendant |
| Patrick's Restaurant, LLC | Sujit Kumar Singh | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2018cv00764 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Patrick J. Schiltz |
| Pacific Union Financial, LLC | Nicholas W. Brownell, Scott C. Smith, John C. Does, Cardinal Financial Company, David Dingman | # 0:2018cv00273 - Other Contract §18:1836 Judge: Franklin L. Noel, jury demanded by Both |
| Patricia Mengesha, BitConnect Investor Group, Co-Lead Counsel, Liaison Counsel | Bitconnect LTD, Bitconnect Trading LTD, PLC Bitconnect International | # 0:2018cv00279 - Contract: Other §28:1332 Judge: Nancy E Brasel, Steven E Rau, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Paul Bunyan Rural Telephone Cooperative | AT&T Corp. | # 0:2018cv00247 - Other Contract §28:1331 Judge: Patrick J. Schiltz, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Prairie River Home Care, Inc. | Procura, LLC | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2017cv05121 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: John R. Tunheim, jury demanded by Both |
| Paisley Park Enterprises, Inc., N.A., Comerica Bank & Trust | LLC, Deliverance, Rogue Music Alliance, George Ian Boxill, LLC | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2017cv01212 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Wilhelmina M. Wright, jury demanded by Both |
| Prudential Insurance Company of America, The | Eric Schilling, Lisa Kearney, Dennis Schilling | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2017cv01146 - Insurance §28:1335 Judge: David T. Schultz |
| Prairie Lakes Municipal Solid Waste Authority | Interstates Construction Services, Inc., Inc., Casey Interstates Partnership, Casey Industrial | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2017cv00738 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| PTR Mechanical | Cincinnati Insurance Company, The | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2017cv00696 - Insurance §12:635 |
| PTR Mechanical, LLC | Cincinnati Insurance Company, The | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2017cv00690 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Wilhelmina M. Wright |
| Polaris Industries Inc. | Trombetta, Inc., Trombetta Electonics, Trumpet Holdings, Inc., LLC, Trombetta, Inc. | # 0:2017cv00289 - Contract Product Liability §28:1332 Judge: Joan N. Ericksen, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| ProSource Technologies, LLC | PGIXS00178-00, Certain Underwriters at London to Lloyd's Subscribing Policies PGIARK04292-00 | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2016cv04356 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: David S. Doty, jury demanded by Both |
| Polaris Sales Inc. | Alex Danze, LSI Products, Inc., LLC, Armor Holdings | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2016cv04181 - Other Contract §28:1441 Judge: Becky R. Thorson, jury demanded by Defendant |
| Patriot's Landing Investment I, LLC | Inc., Arthur Shuster | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2016cv03567 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Katherine M. Menendez |
| Pine River Performance L.P., PRCM Receivables L.P., Pine River Holdings L.P. | Steven Kuhn | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2016cv03102 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Ann D. Montgomery, jury demanded by Defendant |
| Prepared Insurance Company | Zags, Inc. | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2016cv01775 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Donovan W. Frank, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Peerless Indemnity Insurance Company | Sushi Avenue, Inc. | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2015cv04112 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Ann D. Montgomery |
| Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company | Gilbert Odonkor, Margaret Odonkor, Yaw Group Construction Incorporated | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2015cv03450 - Other Contract §28:2201 Judge: Tony N. Leung |
| Progressive Preferred Insurance Company | Pauline L Reagor, Rolayne Renstrom | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2015cv03272 - Insurance §28:2201 Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| POET, LLC | Jones Contracting | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2015cv03248 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Tony N. Leung |
| Pinnacle Credit Services, LLC | LLC, Mary Weil, LLC, Account Portfolio Weil, Management, Lawrence LMM Management, APM Financial Solutions, LLC | # 0:2015cv02917 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Janie S. Mayeron, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Primerica Life Insurance Company | Lori Ann Barbknecht, Dianne L. Iberling, Estate of Jody Bertagnolli, The, Estate of John Bertagnolli, The | # 0:2015cv02858 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Jeffrey J. Keyes |
| Peter Hansen, Jane Hansen | Markel American Insurance Company | # 0:2015cv02833 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Richard H. Kyle |
| Plasti Dip International, Inc. | Rust-Oleum Brands Company, Rust-Oleum Corporation | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2015cv02093 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: John R. Tunheim, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| PMI Nutrition International, LLC | Agribusiness United Multi Commodities, Abou El Abderrahim Ouafa, Inc., Agribusiness United DMCC | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2015cv00610 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Susan Richard Nelson, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Perham Egg, LLC | Pete Klein Trucking, Inc. | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2014cv03478 - Other Contract §49:81 Judge: Richard H. Kyle |
| PNC Bank, National Association | Kenneth Alan Hammarlund | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2014cv03437 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Michael J. Davis |
| Pentagon South, LLC | ITT Educational Services, Inc. | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2014cv03419 - Other Contract §28:1441 Judge: Susan Richard Nelson, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| P.L. Banks, Inc. | Organized Fishing, Inc. | # 0:2014cv03013 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Susan Richard Nelson |
| Provident, LLC | Tim Allen, Larry Van Denend, Precision Flexo & Gravure, Ken Friedman, LLC | # 0:2014cv02941 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Richard H. Kyle, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Progressive Preferred Insurance Company | Dean Morrill, Dan Rasberger | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv01665 - Insurance §28:2201 Judge: Richard H. Kyle |
| Progressive Preferred Insurance Company | Michael Ellsberry, Genea Ellsberry, Barry Brett Stensrud, Stensrud | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv01485 - Insurance §28:2201 Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| Purina Animal Nutrition LLC | Cal Western Packaging Corporation | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00994 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Susan Richard Nelson, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| P.T. Medisafe Technologies | Preventive Care, Inc., Anil Segat | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00974 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Franklin L. Noel |
| Principal Life Insurance Company | Laura Michelle Canty | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00886 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Franklin L. Noel |
| Prudential Insurance Company of America, The | Inc., Patti Sullivan, John M. Vitale, Com-Tal, John Does 1-3, Nordic Electronics, Jason Stenstrom | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00872 - Insurance §28:1335 Judge: Ann D. Montgomery |
| Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company | Rainy Lake Houseboats, Scott Anderson, Ltd., Inc. & WTD Consulting | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00825 - Insurance §28:2201 Judge: Donovan W. Frank, jury demanded by Defendant |
| Penn Industries, Inc., Bert-Co Industries, Inc. | Old Aultsville LLC, Dean Topolinski, Instant Web, Inc. | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00761 - Other Contract §28:1441 Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| , Publishing House of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America | The Hartford Casualty Insurance Company, The Fire Hartford Insurance Company | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00550 - Insurance § Judge: Janie S. Mayeron |
| Police Retirement System of St. Louis, The | Henrique De Castro, Kenneth L. Salazar, Douglas M. Baker‚ Jr., Beth M. Jacob, Roxanne S. Austin, John G. Stumpf, Derica W. Rice, James A. Johnson, Gregg W. Steinhafel, Calvin Darden, Anne M. Mulcahy, John J. Mulligan, Solomon D. Trujillo, Mary E. Minnick | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00551 - Stockholders Suits § |
| Prudential Insurance Company of America, The | Michael Rose, Victor Gabriel, Christine Anna Hunzman | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00382 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Ann D. Montgomery |
| Philip J. Conway, Anthony J. Conway | C.R. Bard, Inc. | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2014cv00301 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: John R. Tunheim, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| PINC, Inc. | Utility Associates, Inc. | # 0:2014cv00212 - Other Contract §9:9 Judge: Paul A. Magnuson |
| Prima Power Laserdyne, LLC | Custom Machines Incorporated | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2013cv03103 - Other Contract §28:1331 Judge: Richard H. Kyle |
| Pro-T, LLC | The Hanover Insurance Company | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2013cv03050 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Patrick J. Schiltz, jury demanded by Both |
| Progressive Universal Insurance Company | Erik Pavlicek, Donald John, Ronald Fischer, Jonathan Kent, Don John Construction | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2013cv02863 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Franklin L. Noel |
| Prospect Communications, Inc. | Tyrone R. Herman | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2013cv02557 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Franklin L. Noel, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Peter Roeser | Bestbuy.com, Geek Squad, Best Buy Co., BBY Solutions, Inc., LLC, Best Buy Stores, Inc., L.P. | # 0:2013cv01968 - Contract: Other § Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| Paccar Financial Corporation | Wendy Golden | # 0:2013cv01737 - Contract: Other § Judge: Janie S. Mayeron |
| Penrod Lane, LLC, Ashraf, LLC | Country Mutual Insurance Company | # 0:2013cv01336 - Insurance § Judge: Tony N. Leung |
| Patricia Bolin, Pamela Miller | Accident Insurance Company, Hartford Life | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2013cv00692 - Insurance § Judge: Patrick J. Schiltz |
| Philip Schouweiler | CNS Corporation, Ozark Life Insurance Company | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2013cv00268 - Contract: Other § Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| Prospect Funding Partners, L.L.C. | Deanna Williams | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2012cv03183 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Paul A. Magnuson |
| Patrick L. Collins, Linda Collins | Depositors Insurance Company | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2012cv03133 - Insurance § Judge: Paul A. Magnuson |
| Perfac, Inc. | Centoco Manufacturing Corporation | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2012cv02955 - Contract: Other § Judge: Patrick J. Schiltz |
| PMP Enterprises, LLC | Travelers Casualty Insurance Company of America | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2012cv02405 - Insurance § Judge: Jeanne J. Graham |
| Perfac, Inc. | Inc., Norazza | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2012cv02266 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Jeffrey J. Keyes, jury demanded by Both |
| Power Generation Solutions Limited (Branch) | MTU Onsite Energy Corporation | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2012cv02203 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: Steven E. Rau, jury demanded by Plaintiff |
| Park Hospitality LLC | Avenue Hotels Management LLC | Filed: Jan 18, 2021 # 0:2012cv02175 - Franchise §28:1332 Judge: Richard H. Kyle |
| Precision Franchising LLC | Inc., Motorscope | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2012cv01905 - Franchise §28:1332 Judge: Susan Richard Nelson |
| PHL Variable Insurance Company | Bank of Utah | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2012cv01256 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Ann D. Montgomery |
| Perham Area Youth Hockey Association | Heritage Hills Golf Resort & Conference Hills Center, Heritage Associates, Inns at Heritage Hills Associates | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2012cv01169 - Other Contract §28:1332 Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| Protective Life Insurance Company | Karen M. Roberts, Cynthia L. Goergen, Lisa A. Curtis, Sheila I. Kridner | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2012cv00582 - Insurance §28:1335 Judge: John R. Tunheim |
| Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company | Separate Solutions, Douglas Lundberg, Inc., W. ROA, Peter Duddleston, Ltd., LLC, North Star Processing, Inc., Michael Doolan, Daniel Ashbach, Separate Solutions, Timothy J. Nicholson | Filed: Jan 17, 2021 # 0:2012cv00542 - Insurance §28:1332 Judge: Ann D. Montgomery, jury demanded by Plaintiff |