Case Search California (CA)

Court Cases CaliforniaCourt records are widely used for a multitude of purposes but whatever your specific reason, their main objective is to provide information. To put it simply, court records provide data in black and white. Ask a Lawyer.

Instant Court Records Search
Criminal Court Records, Civil Court Records, Traffic Court Records
Federal, State, County & Municipal Sources and Much More!


Search for Cases from April 23, 1973 to June 11, 2021

A (20692 rec) B (12462 rec) C (21140 rec) D (17487 rec) E (9696 rec) F (6590 rec) G (9485 rec) H (5903 rec) I (3210 rec) J (30903 rec) K (9433 rec) L (12001 rec) M (24793 rec) N (8009 rec) O (2912 rec) P (9124 rec) Q (349 rec) R (18767 rec) S (26027 rec) T (13777 rec) U (20659 rec) V (4057 rec) W (5107 rec) X (370 rec) Y (1680 rec) Z (778 rec)
Plaintiff /
Defendant Name
Petitioner /
Respondent Name
Filed, Nature of Suit, Judge
Chris Donovan
More Information
Does, Inc., Kydia # 2:2016cv04994 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: George H. Wu
Californians for Alternatives to Toxics
More Information
Hilfiker Pipe Company, Harold K. Hilfiker, Kerry R. Glavich # 3:2016cv04152 -
Environmental Matters §33:1319
Judge: Jon S. Tigar
Christine Goodin
More Information
Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, Volkswagen Group of America Inc # 3:2016cv04212 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1441
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
California Trucking Association
More Information
Julie Su # 3:2016cv01866 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:2201
Judge: Mitchell D. Dembin
Center For Biological Diversity
More Information
Clean Air Council
More Information
Center for Environmental Health
Gina McCarthy # 3:2016cv04092 -
Environmental Matters §42:7604
Judge: Sallie Kim
Claudia Moorman
More Information
Bluestem Brands # 2:2016cv04835 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Michael R. Wilner
Christopher M. Perkins
More Information
Marjorie Perkins
More Information
Enterprise Rent-A-Car, LLC, Enterprise Company Rent-A-Car of Los Angeles # 3:2016cv01863 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:1693
Judge: Marilyn L. Huffjury demanded by Plaintiff
Cynthia Loppe
More Information
Midland Funding LLC, Does # 8:2016cv01340 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Karen E. Scott
Crop Production Services
More Information
Nicholas Claussen, Joey C. Greenberg # 3:2016cv04020 -
Other Statutory Actions §29:1109
Judge: William Alsupjury demanded by Plaintiff
CASSANDRA PYNES
More Information
Portfolio Recovery Associates LLC # 3:2016cv01830 -
Consumer Credit §15:1692
Judge: Bernard G. Skomal
California Sportfishing Protecting Alliance
More Information
Forever Resorts, LLC, LLC, Rex Maughan, Lake Oroville Marina, Bill Harper # 2:2016cv01595 -
Environmental Matters §33:1319
Judge: Morrison C. England
Chaka Franklin
More Information
Rash Curtis & Associates # 3:2016cv03918 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:1692
Judge: Maxine M. Chesneyjury demanded by Defendant
Carneisha Forney
More Information
LLC, Credence Resource Management # 2:2016cv05125 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Frederick F. Mumm
California Sportfishing Protecting Alliance
More Information
Rex Maughan, LLC, Bill Harper, Forever Resorts, LLC, Lake Oroville Marina # 2:2016at00821 -
Environmental Matters §33:1319
Charles Van Der Kooi Dairy
More Information
Henry Jongsma
More Information
Son Dairy
More Information
Cow-West North Star Dairy, Irigaray Dairy
Dairy Employees Union Local No. 17 Christian of Labor Association the United States of America Pension Trust, Dairy Employees Union Local No. 17 Christian Labor Association of the United States of America Pension Trust, Board of Trustees # 2:2016mc00083 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Unassigned
Curt Jacey
More Information
Synchrony Bank # 2:2016cv04592 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Otis D. Wright
Christine Than
More Information
Does, Volkswagen Group of America Inc, Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft # 5:2016cv01476 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Sheri Pym
Corey Logan
More Information
Leon Huff, Kenneth Gamble # 2:2016cv04906 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Gail J. Standish
Christine Goodin
More Information
Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. # 2:2016cv01530 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1441
Judge: Kimberly J. Muellerjury demanded by Plaintiff
Consumerinfo.com
More Information
Esteban Leon # 8:2016cv01261 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Karen E. Scott
Christine Mayberry
More Information
Inc., Volkswagen Group of America # 1:2016at00517 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1441
jury demanded by Plaintiff
Cecelia Richter
More Information
Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. # 3:2016cv03714 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:2301
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
More Information
Chicken Ranch Rancheria of MeWuk Indians
Jerry Brown, State of California # 5:2016cv01347 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Michael R. Wilner
Cynthia Todd
More Information
Experian Information Solutions, Inc, AT&T Corp., Equifax Information Services LLC # 3:2016cv03357 -
Consumer Credit §15:1681
Judge: Elizabeth D. Laportejury demanded by Plaintiff
Curt Jacey
More Information
OneMain Financial Group, LLC # 2:2016cv04613 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Michael W. Fitzgerald
Consuelo Sandoval
More Information
Inc., Inc., Experian Information Solutions, Wells Fargo Card Services # 5:2016cv03344 -
Consumer Credit §15:1681
Judge: Beth Labson Freemanjury demanded by Plaintiff
Cori Hill
More Information
Bluestem Brands # 1:2016at00440 -
Consumer Credit §Civil Miscellaneous Case
jury demanded by Plaintiff
Cathy Smith
More Information
Edward Smith
More Information
Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. # 3:2016cv03177 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:2301
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation
More Information
Compucraft Industries, Inc. # 3:2016cv01572 -
Environmental Matters §33:1251
Judge: Gonzalo P. Curiel
Christian Bustamante
More Information
Monica Bustamante
More Information
Inc., Fidelity Capital Holdings # 5:2016cv01214 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Virginia A. Phillips
Carlita Smith
More Information
Inc., Stellar Recovery # 3:2016cv01441 -
Consumer Credit §15:1692
Judge: Karen S. Crawford
Chong's Produce
More Information
Fresh & Best Produce, Chong Suk Cho, Inc. # 5:2016cv03113 -
Agricultural Acts §07:499
Judge: Nathanael M. Cousins
Chandra Irish
More Information
Jason Irish
More Information
Inc., DOES, Volkswagen Group of America, Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft # 2:2016cv04382 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Sheri Pym
Carman Serrano
More Information
Hector Serrano
More Information
Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, Does, Inc., of Volkswagen Group America # 2:2016cv04395 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Sheri Pym
Corey Lingafeldt
More Information
Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., Volkswagen Atiengesellschaft # 5:2016cv03026 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1441
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
Caryn Tomer
More Information
Yossi Tomer
More Information
DOES, Inc., Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, of Volkswagen Group America # 2:2016cv04401 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Sheri Pym
Carole Eaton-Spring
More Information
Synchrony Bank # 5:2016cv03002 -
Consumer Credit §47:227
Judge: Howard R. Lloyd
Cynthia Vasquez
More Information
Sentry Credit, Midland Funding, LLC, Inc, Inc Midland Credit Management Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv01294 -
Other Statutory Actions §47:0227
Judge: Mitchell D. Dembinjury demanded by Plaintiff
Charlotte Docken
More Information
Limited Liability Company, Petmatrix, Does Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 8:2016cv00994 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Andrew J. Guilford
Cori Hill
More Information
Bluestem Brands # 2:2016cv04140 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Karen L. Stevenson
Cori Hill
More Information
Inc., CMRE Financial Services # 2:2016cv04146 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Karen L. Stevenson
Charles Des Roches
More Information
Sylvia Meyer
More Information
Human Affairs International of California, of California Physicians' Service, Inc.-Employer Services, Magellan Health Services California Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 5:2016cv02848 -
Other Statutory Actions §29:1132
Judge: Howard R. Lloyd
Carol Determan
More Information
Does, Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, Volkswagen Group of America Inc # 3:2016cv03151 -
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations §28:1331
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Both
Coastal Green Vegetable Company LLC
More Information
Eric Saulovich, Elan Foods, Inc., Richard Jose Saulovich, Carbajal, Skip Henderson Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 1:2016cv00726 -
Agricultural Acts §07:499
Judge: Lawrence J. O'Neill
Carey Storm
More Information
Inc., Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, inclusive, Volkswagen Group of America, Does 1 through 20 # 3:2016cv01385 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1441
Judge: Barbara Lynn Majorjury demanded by Defendant
Carlita Smith
More Information
Dynamic Recovery Solutions, Inc. # 3:2016cv01467 -
Consumer Credit §15:1692
Judge: William Q. Hayes
Charles Hise
More Information
Does 1 through 20, Volkswagen Volkswagen Group Aktiengesellschaft, of America Inc # 3:2016cv03048 -
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations §28:1332
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Both
Clipperjet
More Information
American Eagle Finance, Randall Tyson, DOES, Dulany Hill # 8:2016cv01042 -
Racketeer/Corrupt Organization §
Judge: James V. Selna
Cheryl L Persinger
More Information
Allied Collection Service, Trans Union LLC, Inc., Equifax Information Services LLC, Sprint Nextel Corporation, Inc, Diversified Consultants # 5:2016cv01223 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: David T. Bristow

More Information
Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 2:2016cv03526 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Claire Petrosyan
More Information
Universal Fidelity LP # 2:2016cv03913 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Steve Kim
Carrie Couser
More Information
LP, Does, Southwest Credit Systems Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 5:2016cv01044 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Jean P. Rosenbluth
Camille McKinney
More Information
DOES, Inc., Ace Cash Express, Inc., Secure Capital Management Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv01215 -
Consumer Credit §15:1692
Judge: Jill L. Burkhardtjury demanded by Plaintiff
Center for Biological Diversity
More Information
Ventura Coastkeeper, Wishtoyo Foundation
United Water Conservation District # 2:2016cv03869 -
Environmental Matters §
Judge: George H. King
Carolyn Navarro
More Information
Does, Century 21 Real Estate LLC Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 2:2016cv03527 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Frederick F. Mumm
Carlos Olmos Gonzalez
More Information
Equifax Inc., TransUnion Corp. # 5:2016cv02932 -
Consumer Credit §28:1441
Judge: Howard R. Lloydjury demanded by Plaintiff
Charles Henry Most
More Information
United States Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv01292 -
Constitutionality of State Statutes §28:1402
Judge: Jill L. Burkhardt
Caroline Colesworthy
More Information
Volkswagen Group of America, Volkswagen DOES, Aktiengesellschaft, Inc. # 8:2016cv01111 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Sheri Pym
Clarence Haynes
More Information
Allied Interstate LLC Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 2:2016cv03295 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: George H. Wu
Charles Kinney
More Information
ERIC CHOMSKY, Michele R Clark, David Marcus Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 2:2016cv03279 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Philip S. Gutierrez
Cory Steege
More Information
Inc., UPS Ground Freight, UPS Capital Insurance Agency, Inc. Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv02696 -
Commercial/ICC Rates/etc. §28:1441
Judge: William H. Orrick
Courtney Joslin
More Information
Sterling InfoSystems, Inc. Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 5:2016cv00951 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: David T. Bristow
Carlynne Yu
More Information
Rosen, Loeb Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv01113 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:1692
Judge: William V. Gallojury demanded by Plaintiff
Cameron Jordan
More Information
Recovery Service Inc., Does, General Electric Credit Union, Los Angeles Auto Wholesaler Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 2:2016cv03381 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Alka Sagar
Christine Musthaler
More Information
Target Corporation, N.A., Felix A Professional Corporation, Patenaude, TD Bank Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 8:2016cv00888 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Karen E. Scott
Curtin Maritime Corp.
More Information
Avalon Freight Services, Santa Catalina Island Company, LLC Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 2:2016cv03290 -
Anti-Trust §
Judge: Terry J. Hatter
Charles Kinney
More Information
State Bar of California Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv02277 -
Antitrust §15:1
Judge: Maxine M. Chesneyjury demanded by Plaintiff
Christopher Zoidis
More Information
Howard Gurwin
More Information
Kevin M. Heckman
More Information
Jacqueline Peiffer, Virginia A. Durand Trust, Charles L Sommer, Barbara L. Sommer
Inc., T. Rowe Price Associates Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv02289 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1331
Judge: Vince Chhabriajury demanded by Plaintiff
Charles Kinney
More Information
Lynn Chaldu, Does, Charles Viviani, John Three Chaldu, Arch Bay Community Services District Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 8:2016cv00796 -
Environmental Matters §
Judge: R. Gary Klausner
Christine Holt
More Information
Inc., Facebook Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv02266 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1331
Judge: Jacqueline Scott Corleyjury demanded by Plaintiff
Charles Bloom
More Information
Sharon Burnstein
More Information
Brian Wuebbels, Randy H. Zwirn, Inc., Clayton Daley‚ Jr., Inc., Georganne Proctor, Antonio R. Alvarez, James B. Williams, Peter Blackmore, Terraform Global, Ahmad Chatila, SunEdison, Emmanuel Hernandez, Steven Tesoriere Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv02265 -
Securities/Commodities/Exchanges §15:77
Judge: Richard Seeborgjury demanded by Both
Carole Lee Greenberg
More Information
David Moss
More Information
George Cohen
More Information
Roxanne Xenakis
Sunrun Inc., L.P., Gerald Risk, Beau Peelle, Lynn Jurich, Eren Omer Atesmen, LLC, Steve Vassallo, Cred, William Elmore, Richard Wong, Foundation Capital VI, Edward Fenster, Bob Komin, Jameson McJunkin, Foundation Capital Management Co. VI, Reginald Norris Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv02480 -
Securities/Commodities/Exchanges §15:77
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
COR Clearing
More Information
Laura B. Lobue Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 5:2016cv00909 -
Arbitration §
Judge: Kenly Kiya Kato
Carolyn E. Miner As Trustee Of The Milton Miner Family Trust N.A., JP Morgan Chase Bank Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 1:2016at00327 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1331
Celso Borges
More Information
Rash Curtis & Associates Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 4:2016cv01994 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1441
Judge: Jeffrey S. Whitejury demanded by Both
Christie Diosomito
More Information
Global Credit & Collection Corporation Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 5:2016cv02279 -
Consumer Credit §15:1692
Judge: Howard R. Lloydjury demanded by Plaintiff
Cheryl J. Kessler
More Information
Experian Information Solutions, Equifax Services Information LLC, Inc., CitiGroup Management Corp., Trans Union LLC Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv00878 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:1681
Judge: Jeffrey T. Millerjury demanded by Plaintiff
Carmelita Garces
More Information
N.A, Citibank Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 5:2016cv01863 -
Consumer Credit §15:1692
Judge: Lucy H. Koh
Celine Van Wegen
More Information
Inc., Global Equity Finance Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv00815 -
Other Statutory Actions §47:0227
Judge: Mitchell D. Dembinjury demanded by Plaintiff
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
More Information
Davit Gasparyan Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 2:2016cv02725 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Philip S. Gutierrez
Christopher Dwaynne Meuth
More Information
Volkswagen Group of America Inc, Volkswagen of America Inc Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv02076 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:2301
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
County of San Joaquin
More Information
Delta Transport, Richard Churches, H&H Marina Properties, LLC, David Johnson, Joseph Zeiter, Helen's Marina, Mario Sculatti, Charles Spurlock, Herman, Inc., John Campagna, Joseph Faso Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 2:2016cv00816 -
Environmental Matters §33:1365
Judge: Kimberly J. Muellerjury demanded by Defendant
City of Long Beach
More Information
Plains All American Pipeline LP, Does Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 2:2016cv02730 -
Environmental Matters §
Judge: Philip S. Gutierrez
Cynthia Prosterman
More Information
Jan Marie Brown
More Information
Carolyn Fjord
More Information

More Information
Katherine R. Arcell, Keith Dean Bradt, Judy Bray, Jose M. Brito, Robert D. Conway, Judy Crandall, Rosemary D'Augusta, Brenda K. Davis, Pamela Faust, Don Freeland, Donna Fry, Gabriel Garavanian
American Airlines, Delta Air Lines, Inc., Airline Tariff Publishing Company, Inc., Inc., United Airlines Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv02017 -
Antitrust §15:1
Judge: Maxine M. Chesneyjury demanded by Plaintiff
Cassandra Naylor
More Information
Volkswagen Group of America Inc, Volkswagen of America Inc, Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv01547 -
Other Statutory Actions §28:1441
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Defendant
Conexant Systems Inc
More Information
Zykronix Inc Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 8:2016cv00560 -
Arbitration §
Judge: Christina A. Snyder
Colister Slater
More Information
U.S. Department of Homeland Security, Honorable Suzanne Spaulding, Honorable Jeh Charles Johnson, Mr Leonard Eric Patterson Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 5:2016cv00519 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Kenly Kiya Kato
Charles Rozeville
More Information
LLC, Enhanced Recovery Company Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 5:2016cv00604 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: Sheri Pym
Christopher Alarcon
More Information
Galaxy Asset Purchasing, LLC, Global Credit & Collection Corporation Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv00654 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:1692
Judge: Karen S. Crawfordjury demanded by Plaintiff
Construction Laborers Trust Funds for Southern California Administrative Company Sabas Perez Aguilar Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016mc00306 -
Other §
Judge: Unassigned
Carlos Luna
More Information
Inc., Volkswagen Group of America, Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft Filed: Jun 17, 2021
# 3:2016cv01651 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:2301
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
City of Warren Police
More Information
Fire Retirement System
More Information
Herm Rosenman, Roelof F. Botha, Matthew SC XII Rabinowitz, Management, Lightspeed Venture Partners VIII, James I Healy, Edward C Driscoll, John Steuart, Natera, Jr, L.P., Lightspeed Ultima, Inc., Jonathan Sheena, Sequoia Capital XII, LLC, Todd Cozzens, LP Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv01460 -
Securities/Commodities/Exchanges §15:77
Judge: Haywood S Gilliamjury demanded by Plaintiff
Commissions Import Export S.A.
More Information
Republic of the Congo Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 5:2016cv00656 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Sheri Pym
Charter Township of Clinton Police
More Information
Fire Retirement System
Matthew J. Audette, LPL Financial Holdings Inc., Mark S. Casady Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv00685 -
Securities/Commodities/Exchanges §15:0078
Judge: Bernard G. Skomaljury demanded by Plaintiff
Clarence Randle
More Information
Avant, Inc. Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 5:2016cv00487 -
Consumer Credit §
Judge: John F. Walter
Carol Feura
More Information
Synchrony Bank Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv00642 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:1640
Judge: Barbara Lynn Majorjury demanded by Plaintiff
Charles Kinney
More Information
David Marcus, Eric Chomsky, Michele R Clark Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 4:2016cv01260 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:1692
Judge: Laurel Beelerjury demanded by Plaintiff
Charles Roberson
More Information
Charlene Roberson
More Information
Volkswagen Group of America Inc, Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv01217 -
Other Statutory Actions §15:2301
Judge: Charles R. Breyerjury demanded by Plaintiff
Christian Davey
More Information
Navient Solutions Inc Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 2:2016cv01651 -
Other Statutory Actions §
Judge: Jacqueline Chooljian
Cecilia Lopez
More Information
Communications, Dish Network L.L.C., AMG Video Filed: Jun 16, 2021
# 3:2016cv00803 -
Other Statutory Actions §47:227
Judge: Richard Seeborgjury demanded by Both

Back in 1968, the California Public Records Act was passed by state legislature and signed by the then-governor Ronald Regan. The act was put in place to ensure that court and public records would be available and open to the public, without an individual having to disclose why they are requesting said records. This is similar, but not exactly the same as the Freedom of Information Act.

Records can be obtained offline via the following address:

Federal Records Center
1000 Commodore Drive
San Bruno, CA 94066-2350
Phone: (650) 238-3500
Fax: (650) 238-3507
E-mail: sanbruno.reference@nara.gov

Leave a Comment